By Paul F. Roberts
September 27, 2005
Advertising software company Direct Revenue is severing its relationship with
third party Web sites known as "affiliates," according to a company statement.
Direct Revenue LLC said it will stop using affiliate networks as of Sept. 22
and rely exclusively on bundling arrangements with "free advertising-supported
software" to promote its software in the future.
The company did not provide a reason for the decision.
However, a copy of an e-mail message sent to affiliate Web site operators
from Direct Revenue said that the company lost faith in its ability to track the
disclosure and consent practices used to install Direct Revenue software from
affiliate Web sites.
Direct Revenue, of New York, has claimed in the past to have over 20 million
installations of its three ad programs: Aurura, Ceres and SolidPeer, mostly
through bundling arrangements with P2P (peer to peer) software vendors and
arrangements and from one of thousands of affiliate Web sites used by the
company's distribution partners who are paid per installation, said Ari Schwartz
of the CDT (Center for Democracy and Technology) in Washington, D.C.
However, Direct Revenue and other advertising software vendors have been
under pressure from anti-spyware companies, consumer advocates such as Harvard
Law School's Ben Edelman, and from lawmakers, who have already drafted federal
anti-spyware legislation that outlaws certain installation practices.
In a recent analysis of the role of Web sites affiliates in spreading
spyware, Edelman noted that some Web site affiliates sometimes install Direct
Revenue software invisibly and without the user's consent and that pop-up
advertisements delivered through Direct Revenue's clients can create "forced
clicks" that call up affiliate links without the user's consent—basically
corralling the user to a Web site from which the affiliate will profit.
Edelman, CDT and others have also recorded examples of affiliate Web sites
installing bundles of programs on users' machines without their consent using
vulnerabilities in Web browsers.
Programs created by Direct Revenue and competitors, such as 180 Solutions
Inc., are commonly included, along with spyware and pop-up advertising software
in the illegally installed bundles, Schwartz said.
In recent months, Direct Revenue pledged to improve oversight of its network
of Web affiliates.
In a Sept. 22 e-mail to those affiliates with the subject "distribution
practices," however, Direct Revenue said that "the use of affiliate networks by
our partners has made confirmation of accurate and clear disclosure and consent
difficult to track."
Click here
to read more from columnist Larry Seltzer about the reclassification of spyware
and adware.
In an effort to control its distribution channel, Direct Revenue will stop
working with partners who use affiliates and focus on direct bundling
relationships with software providers and distribution partners with which it
has a "direct relationship."
The company is also consolidating its many adware brands under a single
title: The Best Offers Network, Direct Revenue said.
In lieu of software bundles downloaded from affiliate sites, Direct Revenue
offered its distribution partners an "improved method of distribution" that will
display proper disclosure statements to the user prior to installing the Direct
Revenue ad client.
The disclosure will be served directly from Direct Revenue servers, rather
than from the affiliate's servers, the e-mail said.
Ending the use of affiliates will cut off the source of some of the most
egregious installation and disclosure practices.
However, Direct Revenue and other adware companies also need to clean up
their bundling arrangements with companies that make software, like Peer to Peer
clients, that Direct Revenue is bundled with, Schwartz said.
"Do consumers understand that the adware is working, even when they're not
using the advertising supported software it was installed with?" he said.
"That seems to be a difficult concept for the average Internet user to
understand," he said.
Check out eWEEK.com's
Security Center
for the latest security news, reviews and analysis. And for insights on security
coverage around the Web, take a look at eWEEK.com Security Center Editor
Larry Seltzer's Weblog.
|